A gabled Eichler house with a low-slope roof, clerestory glass and a two-car garage on Fairglen Drive in San Jose.

Home › Guides › Skylights during a reroof

Should you replace Eichler skylights when you replace the roof?

Short answerUsually, yes. Eichler skylights tend to fail at the aluminum frame and the wood curb, and they leak through clogged weep holes or from condensation. Replacing them during a reroof lets the roofer flash new curbs into the new roof once. The Eichler Network recommends a reroof as the time to add or replace skylights.

Every roofer we work with is licensed and insured.

Updated · Sources reviewed November 17, 2026 · By Eichler Roof Replacement

  • Active C-39 roofing license, checked on CSLB
  • Contractor's bond and workers' comp on file
  • Low-slope systems: foam, built-up, modified bitumen, single-ply
  • Free written estimate, no obligation

Why Eichler skylights fail

The Eichler Network lists the usual problems (Let the Sun Shine In):

  • Condensation where radiant-heated rooms meet older single-dome skylights.
  • Aluminum frames and wood curbs that deteriorate.
  • Weep holes that clog. Caulking over them "can make the problem worse."

Why do it with the roof

A new skylight needs flashing tied into the roof membrane. Doing it during the reroof means one crew, one set of flashing details and one warranty. The Eichler Network names a reroof as the time to add or replace skylights (Roofing Survival Guide).

Design rules

  • Sunnyvale: the city has a residential skylights page and Eichler design guidelines that ask for integrated roof elements (Sunnyvale, Sunnyvale guidelines).
  • Marin County (Lucas Valley): skylights are among the items listed as exempt from Lucas Valley design review in county summaries (Marin County Code). Confirm with the county.

What to ask

  1. Double-glazed or single dome, and how will you handle condensation?
  2. New curbs or reuse the old ones?
  3. How is the curb flashed into the new roof system?
  4. Who warrants the skylight and who warrants the flashing?

Every roofer we work with is licensed and insured.

Book a free roof inspection

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a permit for a new skylight?

Often. Sunnyvale lists residential skylights among its permit topics (Sunnyvale). Ask your city, and your roofer.

Is it condensation or a leak?

Condensation forms on the cold dome when warm, radiant-heated air hits it and runs out the weep holes or drips. A leak shows up during rain. The Eichler Network describes both (Let the Sun Shine In).

Sources

Sources reviewed November 17, 2026. Confirm permits, design rules and requirements with your contractor and your city or county. This page is general information, not legal or insurance advice.

CallBook inspection