What did the original roofs have?
Very little. Eichler Network writers describe the original insulation as "less than an inch of fiberglass, flattened under a heavy load of tarpaper and thick gravel" (Roof Insulation) and "almost useless" (Eichler Roofing). Owners who add insulation during a reroof mostly notice it in summer, when a dark, uninsulated roof turns the house into what the Eichler Network calls a hot box (Eichler Air Conditioning).
Foam board or spray foam?
Rigid foam board comes in 4-by-8-foot panels fastened to the deck with long screws, large-head nails or adhesive. A tar and gravel, torch-down or single-ply membrane goes on top. Boards can shrink with age, so they need to be well secured (Roof Insulation).
Spray polyurethane foam goes on as a liquid and expands. Its closed cells hold an insulating gas, which gives it about 20 percent more R-value than board foam of the same thickness, and the same layer waterproofs the roof once it's coated.
The Eichler Network suggests R-19 as a good target for a Bay Area Eichler and says going much past it may not be noticeable. It also reports that an insulated tar or torch-down roof costs about the same as a sprayed foam roof, and an insulated single-ply roof is usually the most expensive (Roof Insulation).
What does the Energy Code require?
When more than half of a low-slope roof is replaced, including a new layer over the old one, §150.2(b)1I applies:
| Climate zone | Continuous insulation | Bay Area Eichler areas |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | No requirement | Peninsula, San Francisco, Oakland |
| 1, 2, 4, 8 to 16 | R-14, or roof assembly U-0.039 | San Rafael (2), Santa Clara Valley (4), Walnut Creek and Concord (12) |
Exceptions cover roofs that already have R-10 continuous insulation, and spots where the added thickness would leave flashing at rooftop equipment, walls or wall openings shorter than the manufacturer allows. Climate zones are from the CEC map. Castro Valley and unincorporated Marin straddle zones, so check your address.
What happens at the roof edge?
Insulation makes the roof thicker. On an Eichler the edge is a thin, exposed line with beam ends and fascia below it, so two or more inches of foam changes how the edge looks and how the gravel stop or drip edge is detailed. Ask each roofer to sketch the new edge. In San Rafael's Eichler overlay, raising a roof more than six inches triggers design review (SRMC 14.14.030). Edges, beams and skylights.
Does insulation help with ponding?
It can. Tapered insulation boards add slope toward drains. The Eichler Network notes some building departments require positive drainage at reroof, and building it up with insulation adds cost (Roofing Survival Guide).
Every roofer we work with is licensed and insured.
Book a free roof inspectionFrequently asked questions
Can I add insulation without replacing the roof?
Not on an Eichler. With no attic and an exposed plank ceiling, the only place to add insulation is above the deck, which means during a reroof (Eichler Network).
Is spray foam better than foam board?
Spray foam insulates and waterproofs in one closed-cell layer and has about 20 percent more R-value than board foam of the same thickness, per the Eichler Network. Board foam under a membrane lets you choose tar and gravel, modified bitumen or single-ply on top.
Do I need R-14 if my roof already has some insulation?
Maybe not. Existing roofs with R-10 or more continuous insulation are exempt from the R-14 rule (§150.2(b)1I). Your roofer can check what's there at tear-off.
Sources
- Eichler Network: Roof Insulation
- Eichler Network: Eichler Roofing
- Eichler Network: Eichler Air Conditioning
- 2025 California Energy Code §150.2(b)1I, roof alterations (Energy Code Ace)
- California Energy Commission: Climate zone tool and maps
- San Rafael Municipal Code ch. 14.14: Eichler and Alliance Homes overlay
- Eichler Network: Roofing Survival Guide
Sources reviewed November 17, 2026. Confirm permits, design rules and requirements with your contractor and your city or county. This page is general information, not legal or insurance advice.
